Sick, and Getting Sicker
Kim , New York: Apr 10 2008
Made Popular Apr 10 2008
Russia :

Sick, and Getting SickerRussia is a nation with yearly medical doctor salaries that average $5,160 to $6,120 while nurses make an average of $2,760 to $3,780 annually. That means a top-end doctor, like a surgeon, is only making about $500 per month, less than the national average of around $650 (the “average” isn’t a useful indicator of actual income, however, because it’s skewed by the bizarre level of income paid to Russia’s super-rich oligarchs). Contrast this with the fact that Moscow was rated two years running as the world’s most expensive city to live in (Russia is on pace this year to exceed 20% annual consumer price inflation, after nearly reaching 12% last year — the inflation rate on basic commodities average people can afford is even higher), and you have Russia’s medical profession in a perilous vice. As a result, many Russian physicians turn to corrupt practices like selling drugs on the black market and demanding bribes from patients in order to make ends meet.

Given that background, you will not be surprised to learn that Russia has only 200,000 of the 600,000 physicians it needs as a nation. Who would want to enter the profession on those terms? Russia “spends only three percent of its GDP on health, a figure that is only half of what it should spend and one that puts Russia near the bottom of developed countries” according to scholar Paul Goble, translating a Russian report by Leonid Roshal, the director of the Moscow Research Institute on Emergency Pediatric Surgery and Traumatology. And of that measly 3%, up to a third will be siphoned off by corruption before it ever reaches those it was intended to support. “Today is a favorable moment for Russia. There are both money and the chance to do something,” says Roshal. Goble reports: “But on the basis of Moscow’s recent actions, he lamented, there is little reason for anyone to expect that any significant increase in funding will occur any time soon.” Russia doesn’t rank in the top 100 world nations for male adult lifespan, and faces one of the world’s worst AIDS crises as well as serious problems with smoking and alcohol fatalities.

Roshal understands that Russia’s dictator Vladimir Putin would rather spend the nation’s fossil fuel proceeds on buzzing America with strategic bombers and helping Iran go nuclear. He knows that a major investment by Putin in healthcare would only create a more vibrant population, one more capable of organizing protest actions against his draconian crackdown on democracy. Putin prefers for Russians to stay weak and sick, thus easier to control, freeing even more funds for his crazed reinvigoration of the cold war.

Incidentally, the situation in the legal profession is little better. Goble points to a recent interview by Igor Trunov, head of the Central Bureau of Lawyers in Moscow, condemning the level of preparation of the country’s lawyers in light of a recent announcement by Moscow State University, the Russian Harvard, that “the diplomas of lawyers trained at the University’s law faculty after 1992 may be declared invalid because of shortcomings in training they received there.” This means that lawyers are in no position, as they might be in more developed countries, to root out corruption and incompetence in the medical profession, making the situation even worse.

I reported on Tuesday that Putin had stated at the NATO summit that Ukraine is “not a state” and has no right to existence independent of Russia — basically the same attitude he takes towards Chechnya. It seems that Putin actually wants to provoke his neighbors, and the world’s most potent military alliance, into a new cold-war conflict even though he himself is without allies, even as his own nation is literally going extinct because of illness it has no ability to treat. The world’s journalists need only get out of bed to be confronted by examples of Putin’s belligerence, but they can search the live-long day and not find a single example of Putin demanding a rise in doctor salaries.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
1 Stars
Christian
Wellington, New Zealand
Putin has taken Russia to the cul-de-sac from where it can never return to normalcy. He couldn’t have got a better opportunity after collapse of USSR; the oil prices have sky-rocketed, the world market is looking for avenues to grow and expand; the people have become more tolerant.

But still Putin managed to screw all this up. Hats off to him.
1 Stars
That is pretty pathetic for a qualified doctor. Young Indian doctors working in government hospitals make more money than that. If this trend continues nobody will want to become a doctor in Russia. And the Russian people, god save them.
1 Stars
Arnold
Kiev, Ukraine
Putin should better take care of healthcare system in Russia. The system is in need of a root and branch reform in the old healthcare system, it has not been seriously reformed since the disintegration of the USSR and currently facing two serious problems - severe funding shortages and overpopulation of staff.
1 Stars
Ali
Liverpool, United Kingdom
Yes, medical professionals' condition is very poor in Russia. I found during my visit to Russia that they were poorly paid and forced to sell prescription drugs to other drug syndicate to earn money. The government had once convicted 20 medical professionals two years back in Rostov.
1 Stars
Erkut
Ankara, Turkey
Ali showed dark side of Russian healthcare system in his comment above. Several physicians are involved in double job just to increase their earnings. some of them are seriously thinking to leave the job in government sector to earn good money in private clinics. Despite the excellent GDP growth in Russia, the healthcare system is lagging behind other sectors.
1 Stars
Gibson
Gwalior, India
Yes, agree that there is an acute shortage of healthcare professionals in Russia these days. They are not entirely due to the reasons you have cited. During the Soviet days almost 70 percent of the doctors there were females. These days females in Russia are not interested to take up the profession and for the males it is not a traditional thing.

As far as your assumption of Putin's motives are concerned to keep the nation ill and frail, I strongly disagree. The healthcare system in the USSR was world class and right there on the top. If Putin is following his old paymasters' ways then he would have given healthcare top priority.

Therefore, in my opinion you are completely biased and your article is bereft of any logic or concrete evidence. This is just an anti-Putin rant.
1 Stars
Juha
Helsinki , Finland
"Russia is a nation with yearly medical doctor salaries that average $5,160 to $6,120"

This according to you is AVERAGE. Don't tell us that there are no Russians doctors who earn more than the national average.
1 Stars
Leon
Manchester, United Kingdom
Russia has some of the world's finest medical schools. People from developing nations go there to study medicine. Education for Russians in those schools are highly subsidised just as education in any other stream. Why do you think then the leadership is to be blamed for lower number of physicians than needed in the country? Putin is not stopping Russian students from studying and subsequently practice medicine.
1 Stars
Mick
Dublin, Ireland
Putin is not spending as much on health care than he should or is capable of and using much of the recent oil money modernising his forces and missiles. But in USA too government spending on health care and child health insurance is a hot political matter. There are constant accusations that the government is willing to spend hundreds of billions of dollars in wars which are not in the best interest of America.

What Putin is doing is not too different from what other major world powers are doing that includes Britain and America. One more thing. Spending on health care and the number of physicians are not co-related.
1 Stars
Sebastien
Paris, France
It has become too fashionable for Western Russia observers and analyst to blame Putin for each and everything that ails Russia. Putin is a dictator and there cannot be much argument on this. He has systematically silenced his critics and opposition and now is ruling the country through proxy that will gain some sort of legitimacy when he will be elected as the prime minister. That doesn't mean that Putin is bullying prospective Russian students from taking up medicine as their careers. Now you may argue that why would anyone choose to be a doctor when the earnings are so less. Earning $500 dollars a month is a very good income for a Russian given the fact that a large number of Russians live in hand to mouth existence. If the national average income is $650 then one must take into account the number of multi-billionaires Russia has. It is simply mind-boggling.
1 Stars
Leon
Manchester, United Kingdom
To say Putin wants the Russians stay sick and weak so that he can wield better control over them like the days of cold war is preposterous. During the cold war days an average Russian's health was much better than that of his American counterpart. Medical facilities were free and there were extremely well trained doctors dispensing the best possible treatment in the world.

Russians doctors also pioneered many groundbreaking techniques and technology for treatment. Some where so advanced of their times that the rest of the world laughed at them like freezing a man with ice before conducting a surgery of a vital internal organ.
1 Stars
Arash
Tehran, Iran
It seems you have lost the plot of your own story. Else could you please explain how come Putin's remarks on Ukraine and NATO along with his intentions to provoke Russia's neighbors and Chechnya suddenly find place in the article that seemed to promise something else?

I thought the article was on the state of Russia's healthcare system and diminishing numbers of physicians and the role of the state and the Russian leadership towards it. Is this an analytical report or a political rhetoric?
1 Stars
Didier
Moscow, Russia
How many countries in the world do you see politicians going on a nationwide campaign for rise in doctors' salaries? With Russia it becomes even more ridiculous because of the geopolitical role it has in world affairs that it inherited from the USSR. Putin is now busy consolidating his position in Russia and stifling opposition and dissent. He has more important things to attend to than lose sleep over a lowly doctor's earnings.
1 Stars
Avneet
Manchester, United Kingdom
The threat of de-recognising lawyers who passed out after 1992 is a very serious thing that should be resisted at all levels inside Russia. Can you imagine the design behind it? Either you are a lawyer from the days of the old system or a lawyer from the 'new old system'. This will significantly compromise any legal challenges against Putin. This is far more alarming than the deliberate attempt of depriving common Russians of doctors and medical facilities. Far more sinister.
1 Stars
Mladen
Berlin, Germany
It is unfortunate to see that the hope Russians had for freedom after the collapse of the Soviet Union has evaporated so rapidly. Putin was a mighty popular leader when he took over power but unfortunately he saw virtue in ruling the country in the old-fashioned way where absolute control and no opposition meant smooth functioning of the democracy.

I have a feeling that Putin is still very popular despite the widening gap between the rich and the poor and lack of credible political opposition due to Putin's dictatorial approach of ruling the government. I won't say the hope is completely lost as we are seeing increased activism against him from within Russia and icons like Garry Kasparov picking up the cause of a free and transparent Russia.
0 Stars
Samir
Shimla, India
some astonishing figures..
0 Stars
Samir
Shimla, India
aptly named sick and getting sicker
Add your Comment