The National Illusion
Kim , New York: Jun 1 2008
Made Popular Jun 2 2008
Russia :

The National Illusion

If my writing on Russia can be said to have a theme, it’s probably “bursting bubbles.” The way I see it, Russian people very often choose to dwell in a world of illusions that simply does not correspond to reality. They choose to live, in other words, just as they did in the USSR, and I find this outrageously stupid since the inability to perceive reality, and reform accordingly, is what destroyed the USSR. Russians have even gone so far as to choose to be ruled by a proud KGB spy, as if they wanted to take a do-over on the whole Soviet experience.

Recently, appearances would indicate four sensational successes for Russia in international competition. But if you look beneath the surface just a little, you see that instead of celebrating Russians should be reforming. Yet, as always, they depressingly do the former, not the latter.

So-called Russian Maria Sharapova ascended to the #1 world ranking in tennis. She’s the first Russian ever to occupy the top spot. Wow, great Russian achievement, right?

Not so fast. Sharapova has lived almost her whole life in the United States, learned her game there, and owns real estate there (but none in Russia). In fact, she spends virtually no time in Russia at all. And the only reason she’s number one now is that the actual best player in the world, Justine Henin of Belgium, suddenly decided to retire.

Admit it. You’re a little bit less impressed now, aren’t you? Maybe a lot less?

Then there was Russia’s win for best song at the Eurovision song contest. An impressive stride for Russian culture, huh?

Maybe not. The song was written and produced by Americans, and the general consensus is that it sucks. Have you downloaded it? Thought not.

Next came Russia’s win at the hockey world championships. A demonstration of frozen Russia’s potency in icy sports?

Not really. It’s the first time wintery Russia, which should dominate the sport, has won the title in 15 years, and the only reason it did so was a freak penalty involving the puck leaving the ice that left its opponent short-handed in overtime. Viewers were reminded that mighty Russia hasn’t been able to generate its own home-grown professional circuit, and therefore sends most of its top players to America to earn their livings.

And finally there was Russia’s big win at the UEFA soccer championship in Manchester England against Great Britain. Russia is suddenly a force to be reckoned with on the pitch, right?

As if. Russia was lucky enough to draw a British side that hadn’t seen the finals in four decades, and the Russian side was coached by a Dutchman and its star player was a Ukrainian.

Now, don’t get me wrong. A responsible person might very well say that Russians should see dramatic need to reform their sports establishment in these events, but that’s not the lack of reform I’m complaining about. Because, you see, Russia isn’t a country that can afford to concern itself with luxuries like sports. Russia is suffering from a horrific demographic crisis, with far more funerals each year than births (experts have even coined a new term for Russia’s problem, they’re calling it “hypermortality”). It has one of the world’s worst AIDS crises, and is doing nothing about it. It has virulent problems with alcoholism and smoking, and an emaciated medical establishment incapable of addressing them even if it were inclined to do so. So focusing the national attention on sports victories, even real ones rather than mere illusions, would be an atrocity.

And that’s to say nothing of Russia’s KGB-sponsored crackdown on civil society. Russia no longer has a real media establishment or a genuine opposition political party, nor does it have even vaguely independent local government. All the values of civilized, modern society are under direct threat of absolute extinction. The European Court for human rights is swamped with cases from Russians complaining that their own national court system can’t be trusted to treat them fairly, and Russia has lost far more cases before that tribunal than any nation in world history.

Meanwhile, Russians are dancing the streets, fiddling like Nero while their country is ablaze.

Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Marat
Moscow, Russia
HA Ha! there is kim again. hi so you are back again with your inane phraseology that no one cares for. lOLLLLLLLLLLLLZZZZZZZ. you wry anything Prussian and its achievements for the reason being unknown. Now Sharapova is the target. she is a no 1 player in the world only because she has lived in US. she reached on no 1 ranking coz Justine Henin retired. anything else kim that you can support this with.ppl just wait in her next post Kim will tell you that Sharapova tied Henin...and so on. there is no end to her insanity against Russia , you can expect anything from her.
1 Stars
Bradley
Columbus, United States
Mart

Mart, kim is right in her finding out the truths against Russia. you may criticize her but if that is certainly the case with the sports with Russia and they are learning the expertise from outside (USA) and winning the gold for Russia then the golds belong to US and not to Russia. there are some other questions: with the Booming economy (as some say) and push up that Russian natural sources has given to its economy, where the money is going after all - in Putin's or in yours coffers Mart?
0 Stars
Kim publiuspundit.com/
New York, United States
MARAT:

My heartfelt thanks for your comment! You’ve proved my point in a nutshell. You sound so much like Soviet propaganda from the old days, I almost feel like I should pay you for your words. Bravo! Encore!

Meanwhile, it’s sad that you hate your country so much that you want to destroy it all over again.
1 Stars
Denis
Moscow, Russia
KIM:

Meanwhile, it’s sad that you hate your country so much that you want to destroy it all over again.



A Republican war moll loves Russia so much that she is bitching around the world with stories concocted out of imaginations made vivid by mushroom and acid. Your love for Russia is truly remarkable. Sometimes I wonder if you are a Russian defector to the West or just another Western anti-Russian ranter.
2 Stars
Edward balkanbaby.blogspot...
London, United Kingdom
Ummm... without being too picky, maybe you should research a little more before you publish. The piece about football (soccer as you call it) is simply inaccurate.

It was the UEFA Cup, not the UEFA Soccer Championships.

It was not Russia against Great Britain but Zenit St Petersburg against Rangers (a team from Glasgow in Scotland). Even had it been national teams then it could never be Great Britain since the constituent countries of the United Kingdom play football seperately, as England, Wales, Scotland and Wales.

Furthermore, I don’t quite understand what you are saying about ”a British side that has not seen the finals for four decades”... Rangers regularly qualify for the final rounds of the UEFA Cup and sometimes even get some respectable results in the Champions League, so I don’t quite understand where you picked the four decades business from.

To then rubbish them on having a Ukranian striker, well, this shows a lack of understanding of the sad globalisation of European football. Take Arsenal, they have regularly started matches this season without a single English player. Chelsea only have four English players who regularly start. Manchester United’s star player is Portugese. When AC Milan were at their peak, their star player was a Ukranian, Shevcenko, and Inter Milan’s star striker today (the highest earning player in the Italian League) is a Swede of Bosnian descent. Zenit St Petersburg have proportionately more Russians in their side than most other teams have players from their respected countries.

Personally I can’t stand the power that Russia has. It is a destabilising country which bullies and threatens. And yes, the Eurovision song was awful. All I am doing here is picking you up on factual inaccuracies. How can we afford to criticise if we aren’t even telling the truth ourselves?
0 Stars
Kim publiuspundit.com/
New York, United States
EDWARD:

The problem you have is because you think this post is about soccer. It’s simply not. It’s about Russian nationalism. Regardless of what YOU see, RUSSIANS see the soccer match as a nationalist one, and they are taking credit for the team as if it was comprised of Russians. It’s not, and it didn’t beat a high quality opponent. Those are all unquestionably facts, and the only ones that matter to me. I’m not a soccer fan, I couldn’t care less about it, and the technical points you are making are totally irrelevant to my point.
2 Stars
Edward balkanbaby.blogspot...
London, United Kingdom
If factual consistency is ”totally irrelevant” then I feel that says a lot about your writing. I only picked up on the football points because I am interested in football and watched the particular game in question. Maybe others would be able to pick up on other factual errors in other fields.

Whilst the gist of what you are saying remains in the article, by having such elementary mistakes you lessen the validaty of your point. The errors you made were unnecessary. You could have gone to such basic sites as wikipedia or BBC Sport and you would have been able to find the correct information in less than 10 minutes. Surely that isn’t too much extra work is it?
1 Stars
Denis
Moscow, Russia
Edward:

'Research' and 'factual accuracies' had never been Kim's strength. Hearsay and lies (of the propaganda kind) had always been her forte. She is also a pathetic spin master. If you checked her comments to counter-comment on her articles, you would know what exactly I mean to say. Of course, be careful with her. She uses profanity liberally.
Add your Comment